To report a claim during normal office hours, please call our office direct at:
Geneva: (315) 789-0001
Waterloo: (315) 539-5500
Toll-free: (877) 896-9702
For an Erie Insurance Glass Claim: (800) 552-ERIE
After hours, holidays or weekends, you can call the following carriers direct:
| Erie Insurance Group: | (800) 458-0811 | |
| Hanover Insurance Group: | (800) 628-0260 | |
| Progressive/Drive Insurance: | (877) 776-2436 | |
| Safeco Insurance: | (800) 332-3226 | |
| AIG Insurance: | (877) 638-4244 | |
| AutoOne Insurance: | (866) 252-4669 | |
| GuideOne Insurance: | (888) 748-4326 | |
| Midstate Mutual Insurance: | (800) 826-8520 | |
| Wayne Cooperative Insurance Company: |
(800) 724-1648 | |
| First Rehabilitation: | www.FirstRehab.com | |
| Foremost Insurance: | (800) 527-3907 | |
| Travelers: | 1-877-878-2468 | |
| Preferred Mutual: | (800) 333-7642 | |
| Merchants: | (800) 462-1077 | |
| NYCM/ACentral: | (800) 355-5220 | |
| Adirondack: | (866) 992-4368 | |
| National General/GMAC: | (877) 468-3466 | |
| Farmers: | (800) 435-7764 |
